Maybe she's born with it.

Her: "Are you wearing makeup?"

Me: "Yes."

Her: "Are you wearing mascara??"

Me: "No. Just eyeliner."

Her: laughing, "Oh, I was going to ask you what brand you use."

Me: also laughing, "No, just the eyeliner today. These are natural."

Her: "I want mine to look like that."

Me: "Well when I do, I use Maybelline."

Her: laughing, "Okay. I'll keep that in mind next time."